The RSA is what it is. Just because it's not the best for our car does not mean the other Goodyear tires are bad. The GS-D3 and the F1 Asymmetric are both rated very highly by TireRack's own testing (and not the user reviews, I could give two

for how much I think user reviews are pointless). I'll probably end up with the GS-D3 or Asymmetric myself.