Will sanding and buffing bring these back to like new condition? They seem pretty far gone.
I left mine in place and masked them off to protect the paint finish, then used toothpaste and a buffing tool, rinsing all the time. Took me a couple hours but they came out looking near new. There are previous posts about this and many different ways to accomplish the same end but a lot of elbow grease is needed.
The good news i don't have to spend any time, i found a spare set of headlights in the garage, forgot i had another good pair 😂Oh and OP, it really comes down to how much time you want to spend. Yours look pretty bad (at least in the 2nd pic) and will take a bunch of sanding. I spent several hours on mine, and I think yours are a bit worse than mine were. But it can be made to look almost like new.