If you have an '09 or '10, they changed the oil return line by straightening it out from the turbo and you cannot just slide the wp out. You will have to remove the turbo. That's why the shop manual states that the turbo must be removed. I have seen this!!!I wish there was a step by step instruction PDA or something in the way of detailed instructions on how to change out our water pumps using all the appropriate tools (full circle water pump holder, etc...), and ways to absolutely prevent the dreaded chain-tension whine afterwards. The possibility of not doing something correctly during the changing of the water pump & getting the whine is what's keeping me from buying all the necessary parts to change this out myself. I'd hate to create more work for myself, despite loving to wrench on my cars myself.