Pontiac Solstice Forum banner
1 - 20 of 25 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
I spoke to my insurance agent about insuring my recently acquired 2008 Solstice GXP. The agent was not able to give much information about whether or not I should put theft and accident damage on the insurance.

One of my major goals in life is to keep a low overhead as I don't like to be encumbered by unnecessary bills. At the same time, I am fully aware that properly spent money for the proper reasons is a properly good thing.

That all being said the agent said it would be an extra $10 a month for theft. She said she had no idea how much if any amount of money the insurance company would pay if the car was stolen. She said it would depend upon the value. I don't know what book she is referring to.

As far as putting car accident damage reimbursement insurance on, I believe, though not sure, I don't remember at the moment, it was also approximately $10 a month. She again was not sure at all about how much would be covered.

In both cases mentioned above there are obviously different levels of deductibles that would affect the rates. She was referring to a 1000 deductible which delivers a $10 a month rate for adding theft and another for adding $10 a month for accident damage coverage.

I know it's only $10 or so a month each. However, it is been my experience that $10 + dollars + plus $10 plus $10, ad infinitum, equals added stress which doesn't necessarily fit my lifestyle. It bears repetition though: money well spent is money well spent. I'm not adverse to it, just would rather avoid it if it's not going to be a wise expenditure.

Does anybody have any knowledge about insuring these vehicles vis-à-vis such things as generally how much do insurance companies generally pay if one of these car is stolen? Do they do a decent job of covering car accident damage? Is it worth getting these types of insurance or not worth it? Just general opinions would be just fine, and of course appreciated, as he understand exact answers are not possible.

has anybody had one of these car sadly stolen? has anybody unfortunately gotten into a car accident and try to put it into insurance? Direct experience in my experience generally but not always leads to highly valuable feedback.

Thank you for any helpful feedback
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
191 Posts
Beings that I work for an insurance company but by no means an agent. I just work in the I.T. dept. Anyway....how most companies value a car, is by looking at how much a car like yours would sell for on the used market for the area you live in. So for me it could be different then it is for you because of maybe the market price difference. This value is used both if stolen or totaled in an accident. But to be honest, squinting $10 here there is just a bit too tight for my taste. Just ask yourself, if your car was totaled or stolen, what can you afford to lose? A $1000 ductable? The whole value of the car period if not fully covered? Get to the deductable level that you can afford if your car has to get repaired or a check for the value minus your deductable. Its all in YOUR affordability. For me full coverage is what I have, there is still value left in my car, so I want to be able to get what I can.

Have you insured other vehicles? Do you have a loan on this car? If so most banks require that you have full coverage to cover their interest.

Scott.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
4,262 Posts
My car is insured through State Farm I pay $ 178.00 for full coverage this is for 6 months out of the year because I store it in the winter months for that I pay $60.00
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
191 Posts
Yea good point Sting Ya, I also have mine as 8500 or less miles so I pay less then I do for my other vehicles. But that is a great price, can't get that in the Baltimore area.

Not sure the age of Mischievious Guru, but I know my insurance company rates the GXP as a performance car, so for young people (24 or less) This can also make their rates higher. Beings that I am older...eh hem...and have a good driving record my rates a good.

But car insurance is one of those necessary evils, and the insurance companies always make sure they stay on top.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sting Ya

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,886 Posts
Hahahahahahahahaha.....you guys are funny!!!

No tickets
No Accidents
Excellent Credit
Live in a low crime area
Less then 20 miles to work
Both cars get used less then 10k/yr

2015 Challenger R/T - full coverage $500 ded. comp.
2008 Solstice GXP - full coverage $500 ded. comp.

$350/mth for insurance in the good old rape state of Michigan!!!

Now to answer your question. By all means for $10/mth, why would take a chance?!?!?! That's $120/yr to insure your car that's worth a minimum of $6000 in the event of an accident or theft. Why would you even ask that question?!?! Unless you can't afford $10/mth, then you should sell it. In which case I'm going to address it the same way I used to address selling a car with a payment of $50/mth more. How much money do you spend on Starbucks every month? How about eating at restaurants? How about smokes? I used to LOVE my customers that would come in and want an MKS but would find out the payment was $50/mth more then they wanted to spend....and most would have their 'evening' Starbucks with them. If we had a good relationship going I would look at them and say, for $50 more/mth, you don't want to drive an MKS? You would rather drive an MKZ?!?! Really?!?! Let me help you afford the car you want....how often do you take your family out to dinner? Oh...3 times a week? How much do you spend at each dinner with your 2 kids? Oh, $75/meal... Do you realize, just one meal will put you in the car you want....and you won't be driving a car you hate for 3 year.

Now that I've gotten off track, my other word of advice is this. IF...and it's a big IF....you pay more for insurance for 1 year then your car is worth, then, and only then do you drop full coverage insurance. At $10/mth for full coverage....I would insure the car till it went to the junkyard!! At $10/mth, you will ALWAYS get your money back if something happens to it. At $10/mth, you could theoretically insure it of 600 months (50years) and still make money if anything happened to it. I'm just going to say it, "quit being cheap and just put the full coverage on it"....unless it's an absolute beater that's worth $100.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
256 Posts
Insurance is nothing more than legalized gambling. You are betting that you need it, and the insurance company is betting that you do not need it. And just like real casinos, the house always wins in the end.

I believe in insuring things that I am legally required to ensure, and things that I cannot afford to lose or do without. I am one of those people that never gets an extended warranty on purchases.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
206 Posts
I am confused. You bought a base Solstice for $6500 and then had buyers remorse and picked up a GXP for $12500 ($6000 more) and now you are worried about $10/month for additional insurance?

If money is tight, you should have kept the NA at $6500.

If the car is that important to you and you couldn't afford to replace it if you wrecked it, get the insurance.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
4,262 Posts
Insurance companies go by what's called the "book value " on a car which is a guide they use , Kelly Blue Book is one source .There are usually 2 listings per car one is wholesale or what a dealer will pay you on a trade in ,and the other is market value or retail what similar cars are selling for in your area . A good insurance company State Farm ,Allstate etc. will take into account the mileage ,condition of the car , options ,and any modifications if you have notified them and can document the changes prior to filling a claim . Another type of insurance is called Agreed Value which some carriers have or you go to a specialised carrier such as Hagerty who deals in collector cars , exotics ,antiques etc. this is basically an agreement between you and the carrier as to the worth of your car so if there is a loss they pay the agreed value . As an example I have a 70 Chevelle SS396 that has an agreed value of $65000.00 if the car were stolen ,totaled ,or they could not find the parts to repair it in the case of an accident this is the amount I would receive. You need to take into account the fact that the car is a convertible (easier to break into ) it's small so it could be hard to see for someone like Granny backing out of a parking space and the places you drive as far as crime goes .My cars the Solstice and Chevelle never leave my sight unless I'm at a cruise in or car show I don't use them as daily drivers .I guess at this point you have to, ask yourself am I willing to risk what could end up being costly repairs or worse yet a total loss all to save a few bucks bottom line for me is that it's a necessary evil .
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 · (Edited)
Beings that I work for an insurance company but by no means an agent. I just work in the I.T. dept. Anyway....how most companies value a car, is by looking at how much a car like yours would sell for on the used market for the area you live in. So for me it could be different then it is for you because of maybe the market price difference. This value is used both if stolen or totaled in an accident. But to be honest, squinting $10 here there is just a bit too tight for my taste. Just ask yourself, if your car was totaled or stolen, what can you afford to lose? A $1000 ductable? The whole value of the car period if not fully covered? Get to the deductable level that you can afford if your car has to get repaired or a check for the value minus your deductable. Its all in YOUR affordability. For me full coverage is what I have, there is still value left in my car, so I want to be able to get what I can.

Have you insured other vehicles? Do you have a loan on this car? If so most banks require that you have full coverage to cover their interest.

Scott.
Scott, that was an excellent response, and you are very informative, and obviously have a lot of information and experience. You just talked me into adding insurance for theft and accident damage.

I have been leasing cars over the past years so yes I have had theft and accident insurance because they had to. no I do not have a loan.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 · (Edited)
My car is insured through State Farm I pay $ 178.00 for full coverage this is for 6 months out of the year because I store it in the winter months for that I pay $60.00
that's a really good price. when you say full coverage, does that mean you have theft and accident on it? No deductible?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
that's a really good price.
a PS on that: you say that you store your car in the winter. I plan on driving this car in the winter. Though I will have a second car soon. Does anybody know to these cars a farewell in the winter? Specifically meaning do they warm up and stay warm in cold weather such as New York? And do they drive reasonably well in inclement weather such as snow and such?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 · (Edited)
I am confused. You bought a base Solstice for $6500 and then had buyers remorse and picked up a GXP for $12500 ($6000 more) and now you are worried about $10/month for additional insurance?

If money is tight, you should have kept the NA at $6500.

If the car is that important to you and you couldn't afford to replace it if you wrecked it, get the insurance.
very valid points. It's not that the money is so tight, I just have this thing about keeping overhead down, I like to be footloose and fancy free, I do where they can to keep my bills down to a minimum, just don't like to stress of having to grind constantly to meet monthly bills as much as possible. Once something is purchased, more or less usually there is not an overhead to deal with. I hope that sheds more light on my thinking process. But, after reading this thread, you all seem to be making a lot of sense, I'm going to add accident and theft. It's not just $10 a month by the way, it's $10 a month for accident, and $10 a month for theft. So it's $20 a month. Not a big deal. Just saying.

and part of my calculations in doing this upgrade is that I got the first car so inexpensive that I expect to hopefully make a profit on it, which will close the gap considerably, I assume, after all is said and done. From what I gather I also seem to have gotten the second car at a very good price, so in the long run it wasn't so much just throwing money around, it was a choice about having more fun, and also since I believe the GXP will hold value better, and instead of De-value, actually it possibly may go up in value, in my opinion, faster, so it actually was probably a better investment.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
Insurance companies go by what's called the "book value " on a car which is a guide they use , Kelly Blue Book is one source .There are usually 2 listings per car one is wholesale or what a dealer will pay you on a trade in ,and the other is market value or retail what similar cars are selling for in your area . A good insurance company State Farm ,Allstate etc. will take into account the mileage ,condition of the car , options ,and any modifications if you have notified them and can document the changes prior to filling a claim . Another type of insurance is called Agreed Value which some carriers have or you go to a specialised carrier such as Hagerty who deals in collector cars , exotics ,antiques etc. this is basically an agreement between you and the carrier as to the worth of your car so if there is a loss they pay the agreed value . As an example I have a 70 Chevelle SS396 that has an agreed value of $65000.00 if the car were stolen ,totaled ,or they could not find the parts to repair it in the case of an accident this is the amount I would receive. You need to take into account the fact that the car is a convertible (easier to break into ) it's small so it could be hard to see for someone like Granny backing out of a parking space and the places you drive as far as crime goes .My cars the Solstice and Chevelle never leave my sight unless I'm at a cruise in or car show I don't use them as daily drivers .I guess at this point you have to, ask yourself am I willing to risk what could end up being costly repairs or worse yet a total loss all to save a few bucks bottom line for me is that it's a necessary evil .
great information. Thank you. Do you think it's a good idea to contact this insurance company mentioned called Hagerty about the GXP?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Insurance is nothing more than legalized gambling. You are betting that you need it, and the insurance company is betting that you do not need it. And just like real casinos, the house always wins in the end.

I believe in insuring things that I am legally required to ensure, and things that I cannot afford to lose or do without. I am one of those people that never gets an extended warranty on purchases.
you and I seem to be akin in personality. though what I said in previous posts about these very wise people who are offering sage advice, and I will for the $20 month put the insurance on, your words still ring true with me, and usually I would do as you, and before I had cars leased, I used to gamble, and in the long run throughout my life I believe I have beat the "house." The Vegas analogy was brilliant by the way. And that's why I stay away from Vegas.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
254 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
Hahahahahahahahaha.....you guys are funny!!!

No tickets
No Accidents
Excellent Credit
Live in a low crime area
Less then 20 miles to work
Both cars get used less then 10k/yr

2015 Challenger R/T - full coverage $500 ded. comp.
2008 Solstice GXP - full coverage $500 ded. comp.

$350/mth for insurance in the good old rape state of Michigan!!!

Now to answer your question. By all means for $10/mth, why would take a chance?!?!?! That's $120/yr to insure your car that's worth a minimum of $6000 in the event of an accident or theft. Why would you even ask that question?!?! Unless you can't afford $10/mth, then you should sell it. In which case I'm going to address it the same way I used to address selling a car with a payment of $50/mth more. How much money do you spend on Starbucks every month? How about eating at restaurants? How about smokes? I used to LOVE my customers that would come in and want an MKS but would find out the payment was $50/mth more then they wanted to spend....and most would have their 'evening' Starbucks with them. If we had a good relationship going I would look at them and say, for $50 more/mth, you don't want to drive an MKS? You would rather drive an MKZ?!?! Really?!?! Let me help you afford the car you want....how often do you take your family out to dinner? Oh...3 times a week? How much do you spend at each dinner with your 2 kids? Oh, $75/meal... Do you realize, just one meal will put you in the car you want....and you won't be driving a car you hate for 3 year.

Now that I've gotten off track, my other word of advice is this. IF...and it's a big IF....you pay more for insurance for 1 year then your car is worth, then, and only then do you drop full coverage insurance. At $10/mth for full coverage....I would insure the car till it went to the junkyard!! At $10/mth, you will ALWAYS get your money back if something happens to it. At $10/mth, you could theoretically insure it of 600 months (50years) and still make money if anything happened to it. I'm just going to say it, "quit being cheap and just put the full coverage on it"....unless it's an absolute beater that's worth $100.
my scolding well deserved, and thank you for that.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,886 Posts
my scolding well deserved, and thank you for that.
hahaha....I wasn't trying to "scold". I was just trying to open up your eyes. Sometimes I come across a little harsh! I'm trying to correct that as even my boss has said I need to "tone down" my corporate emails...hahahahaha..... Then I have to explain that I was in the dealership world for 15 years and I'm still trying to acclimate to the corporate world... :( $20/mth for piece of mind, especially since it's going to be your DD, is nothing. As you can tell from my post, I'm a bit irritated with my insurance premiums.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
191 Posts
I need to move! LOL. I pay about $800 a year for the Solstice as a part time driver. Now I do have the V8 conversion etc. So I do have a few $$ into the vehicle. My other car's about $1100, that is Full Coverage and only $250 ded and $50 ded on Comprehensive.
I guess maryland is as bad as michigan? LOL.

Hagerty will only insure specialty or older part time driven cars. If you are going daily drive this, I would doubt they will insure it. Unless they a regular insurance plan. But they are a specialized insurance company. I would go with the big companies, just a matter of shopping it around to see who has the best price for you. Again, a higher deductable will get you a lower premium, but remember that is what you have pay when you are in an at fault accident or if the car is stolen or totaled, the check you get will be less that amount. I see so many of our insureds that don't have full coverage and have an accident with their 2001 car and it gets totaled and wonder why they don't get any money, we only pay to fix the other claimants vehicles or property damage. and because you don't have full coverage there is no towing and rental.

My recommendation as stated by others, is that since there is value in that vehicle, you want full coverage and just put the deductable level at what you can afford to pay if vehicle is in an accident of your fault, stolen or totaled. All states are different in their fault determination. I know in maryland what deductable you choose is also the deductable for un-insured Motorist. so for example and this has happend to me, You get hit by Jonny not insured, my insurance covers fixing my car minus the deductable even tho it was Jonny's fault! That just sucks in my book, but that is the insurance law here in Maryland. Now you can go after Jonny on your own and sue for the deductable, but good luck with that! Can't get blood from a turnip.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
256 Posts
a PS on that: you say that you store your car in the winter. I plan on driving this car in the winter. Though I will have a second car soon. Does anybody know to these cars a farewell in the winter? Specifically meaning do they warm up and stay warm in cold weather such as New York? And do they drive reasonably well in inclement weather such as snow and such?
Because of traction control, stability control, and anti-lock breaks a GXP does well in rain and light snow. The Eagle F1 tires that came on them did well in light snow. Because the cockpit is small, they heat up quickly.

Now, the big issue. There is a dam under the radiator. You only have 2" of ground clearance. So if you get more than 2" of snow you become a snowplow. Also, the splitter is somewhat fragile. The thought of hitting a chunk of ice that would fall off of another car sent shivers down my spine.

I used to have an older Neon as my fowl weather car. As long as the prediction was for less than 2" of snow, I would drive the Solstice. More than 2", or there were chunks of ice coming off of other cars, and I was in the Neon.
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Top